Anthony M. Esolen

Anthony M. Esolen is a writer, social commentator, translator of classical poetry, and Writer-in-Residence at Magdalen College of the Liberal Arts. He taught at Furman University and Providence College before transferring to the Thomas More College of Liberal Arts in 2017 and Magdalen in 2019.

Esolen has translated into English Dante's ''Divine Comedy'', Lucretius' ''On the Nature of Things'', and Torquato Tasso's ''Jerusalem Delivered''. In addition to multiple books, he is the author of numerous articles in such publications as ''The Modern Age'', '' The Catholic World Report'', ''Chronicles'', '' The Claremont Review of Books'', ''The Public Discourse'', ''First Things'', ''Crisis Magazine'', ''The Catholic Thing'', and '' Touchstone'', for which he serves as a senior editor. He is a regular contributor to ''Magnificat'', and has written frequently for a host of other online journals.

Esolen is a Catholic, and his writings generally contain an identifiable conservative or traditionalist perspective. He has frequently criticized the concept of "diversity" as commonly understood in modern Western culture. Dissatisfaction over some of the views that he expressed contributed to his decision to leave Providence College.

Early life and career

Esolen is of Italian ancestry. He was born in Archbald, Pennsylvania. Anthony Esolen graduated ''summa cum laude'' from Princeton University in 1981. He pursued graduate work at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, where he earned his M.A. in 1981 and a Ph.D. in Renaissance literature in 1987. Esolen's dissertation, "A Rhetoric of Spenserian Irony," was directed by S.K. Heninger. He taught at Furman University from 1988 to 1990.

Providence College

Esolen began teaching English at Providence College in 1990, becoming a full professor in 1995. He earned a reputation as a conservative Catholic author, and grew increasingly dissatisfied with the more liberal direction of Providence College, a Catholic university run by the Dominican Order. He is a critic of "diversity" training and guidelines as practiced at many American colleges and universities. In the summer of 2016, he remarked, "What counts for them as 'diversity' is governed entirely by a monotonous and predictable list of current political concerns. If you read a short story written in English by a Latina author living up the road in Worcester, that counts as 'diverse,' but if you read a romance written in Spanish by a Spanish author living in Spain four hundred years ago, that does not count as 'diverse.'"

In September 2016, ''Crisis Magazine'' published an article by Esolen titled "My College Succumbed to the Totalitarian Diversity Cult." ''Crisis Magazine'' wrote the title for the piece, according to Esolen. In the essay, Esolen argued that Western insistence on diversity as one of its core values was destructive to authentic cultures and was inherently contradictory to the Christian faith. He stated that people can only "be truly at one" when they are united by faith in God. Questioning the very western idea of diversity, he asked:

Esolen held that Catholicism "redeems not only individuals but peoples" preserving their culture as it does so, which is in contrast to "the secular preachers of diversity" who work "their hardest to efface that difference, to muffle all those who speak with the voice of the Church against the vision that those preachers have to offer—a vision that pretends to be 'multicultural,' but that is actually anti-cultural, and is characterized by all the totalitarian impulses to use the massive power of government to bring to heel those who decline to go along." He held that procedures turning over reported bias to a bias response team, was analogous to the infamous Star Chamber. Esolen maintained that initialisms such as LGBT were "the alphabet soup of cheered-on sexual proclivities. For some reason that does not include F, for Fornicators, or S, for swingers, or P, for pornographers, or W, for sex-workers, formerly called harlots, or A, for adulterers." He held that making reference to such as an identifier could not be practiced within Catholicism, since "a disordered inclination" can not be held to be an essential component of anyone. Esolen maintained that non-Catholic faculty within the College were backing the diversity program, in order to raise the question of "Is it permitted for a Catholic, at a college that advertises itself as Catholic, to affirm a Catholic view of sex and the family?" These non-Catholics "have made life hell for more than one of my friends" and some of them "would silence us for good, if they had the power."

Some students and faculty members of Providence College reacted with anger to the publication of the essay. Providence students organized a protest march. A group of faculty members of the school wrote a petition in which they charged that Esolen's writings contained repeated "racist, xenophobic, misogynist, homophobic and religiously chauvinist statements." The Rev. Brian Shanley, O.P., President of Providence College at the time, publicly distanced himself from Esolen's statements by claiming "that he speaks only for himself. He certainly does not speak for me, my administration, and for many others at Providence College who understand and value diversity in a very different sense from him." Meanwhile, Robert P. George, a conservative Catholic professor at Esolen's alma mater, Princeton University, defended him. He argued that students and faculty members who disagree with him "should respond in the currency of academic discourse—reasons, evidence, arguments—not by attempting to isolate, stigmatize, and marginalize him for stating dissenting opinions."

Subsequent career

On May 4, 2017, it was announced that Esolen would join the faculty at Thomas More College of Liberal Arts in Merrimack, New Hampshire beginning the fall of 2017. On this occasion, he criticized the Providence College administration for becoming too "secular." In an essay praising his relationships at his new job, he said working at Providence was like "trying to shore up a crumbling wall" where the leadership was striving to "pass out lemonade to the professors with the sledge hammers."

On May 13, 2019, Esolen resigned from Thomas More citing increased Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy leg pain triggered by travel for speaking engagements and his commute from the college and his home in Warner, New Hampshire. He was able to find a position at Northeast Catholic College located minutes from his home. In 2019, Esolen joined Northeast Catholic College, later renamed Magdalen College of the Liberal Arts, as a full faculty member and Writer-In-Residence.

Literary work

Along with teaching, Esolen has published articles and books on a regular basis. He is a regular contributor to ''Magnificat'' and serves as a senior editor of '' Touchstone''.

Esolen's translation of Dante Alighieri's ''Divine Comedy'' into English was published by Modern Library. His translation of the ''Inferno'' appeared in 2002, the ''Purgatory'' in 2003, and the ''Paradise'' in 2005. In his translations, Esolen chose not to attempt a "preservation of Dante's rhyme in any systematic form." Dante's original Italian work relied heavily on rhyme schemes. However, the English language has fewer rhyming words than the Italian language. Thus, according to Esolen, trying to recreate the sounds of the original rhyme scheme would have compromised "either meaning or music."

In lieu of Dante's famous ''terza rima'', Esolen's translation depends on the use of blank verse. Esolen writes that the use of blank verse allows him to retain both the "meaning nd themusic" of Dante's original. The works also feature, alongside the English translation, the original Italian text. Esolen notes that this text "is based on the editions of Giorgio Petrocchi (1965) and Umberto Bosco and Giovanni Reggio" (1979)." Finally, the translations include Esolen's notes and commentary on the text, as well as illustrations by Gustave Doré. Esolen kept his most extensive notes for the back of each book, so as not to interrupt the reading of the main text. Anne Barbeau Gardiner, a professor emerita of English at the City University of New York, praised the translation for being "not only highly readable, but also vigorous and beautiful."

Esolen has written translations of other classical texts, including Torquato Tasso's ''Jerusalem Delivered'' (reviewed in ''Translation and Literature'', ''Sixteenth-Century Journal'', and ''International Journal of the Classical Tradition'') and Lucretius' ''De rerum natura''. Both were published by Johns Hopkins University Press.

He has argued that the Middle Ages were actually an enlightened time, so that the term " Dark Ages" is a misnomer. He cited the establishment of universities, the development of the carnival, and the contributions of famous saints such as Albertus Magnus and Thomas Aquinas to science and philosophy, all of which took place in the Middle Ages, as examples.

In 2011, Esolen published an essay in ''First Things'' in which he criticized what he saw as the "bumping boxcar language" of the New American Bible. Esolen attacked the NAB translations for " efer ngthe general to the specific, the abstract to the concrete, the vague to the exact." He went on to list several examples of Biblical passages in which he claimed that the true meaning or visceral nature of the words had been eroded.

Publications

Translations

The following works were translated into English by Esolen:

*
*
*
*
*

Books

The following books were written by Esolen:

*
*
*
*
* ''Reflections on the Christian Life.'' Sophia Institute Press. February 20, 2012.
* ''Defending Marriage: Twelve Arguments for Sanity''. May 28, 2014.
* ''Reclaiming Catholic Social Teaching.'' Sophia Institute Press. October 20, 2014.
* ''Life Under Compulsion: Ten Ways to Destroy the Humanity of Your Child.'
Intercollegiate Studies Institute
May 18, 2015.
* ''Real Music: A Guide to the Timeless Hymns of the Church''. TAN Books December 7, 2016.
*
* ''Defending Boyhood: How Building Forts, Reading Stories, Playing Ball, and Praying to God Can Change the World''. TAN Books March 25, 2019
* ''In the Beginning Was the Word: An Annotated Reading of the Prologue of John''. Angelico Press, 2021.

References

External links

Finding the Masculine Genius
An interview with the news service Zenit.

Lost in Translation
An article from the ''Claremont Review''.

Loss Upon Loss
An article from the ''Claremont Review''.
*

The Mighty Child: Visions of Youth in Dante and Shakespeare

Interregnum VII Keynote Address (Part 1)

{{DEFAULTSORT:Esolen, Anthony M.
Living people
Year of birth missing (living people)
Italian–English translators
Latin–English translators
American poets of Italian descent
American Roman Catholic poets
American medievalists
American academics of English literature
Translators of Dante Alighieri
American writers of Italian descent
Princeton University alumni
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill alumni
Magdalen College of the Liberal Arts